OpenAI has fired back at Elon Musk in an intensifying legal dispute, accusing the billionaire entrepreneur of harassment and using the judicial system to gain competitive advantage for his own AI company, xAI. The conflict stems from Musk’s second lawsuit against OpenAI filed in August 2024, where he claims executives “deceived” him into cofounding the organization by exploiting his concerns about existential AI risks.
Musk’s legal team has characterized OpenAI’s transformation from a nonprofit to a “capped-profit” structure as a “textbook tale of altruism versus greed.” The Tesla and SpaceX CEO was among the original cofounders of OpenAI in 2015, alongside current CEO Sam Altman and nine others, establishing it as a nonprofit AI research laboratory. However, Musk resigned from the company’s board of directors in 2018, one year before OpenAI announced its for-profit arm.
In a strongly-worded court filing submitted Tuesday, OpenAI’s lawyers dismissed Musk’s lawsuit as part of an “increasingly blusterous campaign to harass OpenAI for his own competitive advantage.” The filing states that Musk “once supported OpenAI in that mission but abandoned the venture when his bid to dominate it failed.” OpenAI has requested the case be dismissed entirely, arguing that Musk failed to provide adequate factual or legal foundation for his claims.
This legal battle represents the latest chapter in a long-running feud between Musk and OpenAI. In March 2024, Musk filed his first lawsuit on similar grounds but withdrew it in June. Since then, he has maintained a steady stream of public criticism against OpenAI through social media posts and memes on X (formerly Twitter), targeting everything from the company’s fundraising activities to its flagship product ChatGPT and its close partnership with Microsoft.
Musk particularly took issue with OpenAI’s historic $6.6 billion funding round completed in October 2024, which valued the company at $157 billion, making it one of the world’s most valuable startups. He shared reports claiming OpenAI had requested exclusive funding agreements preventing investors from backing five competitors, including his own xAI, along with Perplexity, Glean, Anthropic, and Safe Superintelligence, calling the company “evil.”
Meanwhile, OpenAI is reportedly planning further restructuring to become a for-profit benefit corporation, moving even further from its nonprofit origins. This transition comes during a turbulent period that has seen several high-profile departures, including former CTO Mira Murati and cofounder Ilya Sutskever.
Key Quotes
OpenAI is dedicated to the safe and beneficial development of artificial general intelligence (“AGI”). Musk once supported OpenAI in that mission but abandoned the venture when his bid to dominate it failed.
This statement from OpenAI’s lawyers in their Tuesday court filing directly challenges Musk’s motivations, suggesting his lawsuit stems from failed attempts to control the company rather than genuine concerns about its mission.
Since launching a competing artificial intelligence company, xAI, Musk has been trying to leverage the judicial system for an edge.
OpenAI’s legal team explicitly accuses Musk of using litigation as a competitive weapon, framing the lawsuit as part of a broader harassment campaign rather than a legitimate legal grievance.
textbook tale of altruism versus greed
Musk’s lawyers used this phrase to characterize OpenAI’s transition from nonprofit to for-profit structure, positioning their client as defending the original altruistic mission against commercial interests.
Our Take
This escalating conflict reveals the inherent contradictions in building transformative AI technology within traditional corporate structures. Musk’s criticism, while potentially self-serving given his competing xAI venture, touches on legitimate concerns about mission drift in AI organizations. OpenAI’s journey from nonprofit research lab to $157 billion for-profit entity is unprecedented and raises questions about accountability to original stakeholders. However, the company’s counterargument that Musk sought to “dominate” OpenAI suggests his concerns may be more about control than principles. The timing of Musk’s lawsuits—coinciding with xAI’s growth—certainly supports OpenAI’s harassment claims. What’s most significant is how this dispute exposes the tension between the massive capital requirements for frontier AI development and maintaining commitments to safe, beneficial AI. As the industry matures, expect more such conflicts as early idealistic visions collide with commercial realities.
Why This Matters
This legal battle between Elon Musk and OpenAI represents more than just a personal dispute—it highlights fundamental tensions in the AI industry about the balance between profit motives and the original mission of safe AI development. The case raises critical questions about corporate governance in AI companies and whether organizations can maintain their founding principles while pursuing commercial success.
The conflict also underscores the intensifying competition in the generative AI space, with Musk’s xAI directly competing against OpenAI, Anthropic, and other major players. Musk’s allegations about exclusive funding agreements, if true, could reveal anti-competitive practices that may attract regulatory scrutiny. As OpenAI continues its transformation into a for-profit entity valued at $157 billion, the outcome of this legal dispute could set precedents for how AI startups structure themselves and honor commitments to early supporters and cofounders. The exodus of key executives from OpenAI during this period also signals potential internal disagreements about the company’s direction, which could impact the broader AI development landscape.
Recommended Reading
For those interested in learning more about artificial intelligence, machine learning, and effective AI communication, here are some excellent resources:
Recommended Reading
Related Stories
- Elon Musk Drops Lawsuit Against ChatGPT Maker OpenAI, No Explanation
- OpenAI CEO Sam Altman Hints at Potential Restructuring in 2024
- OpenAI’s Valuation Soars as AI Race Heats Up
- Sam Altman’s Bold AI Predictions: AGI, Jobs, and the Future by 2025
- Elon Musk Warns of Potential Apple Ban on OpenAI’s ChatGPT