Microsoft’s ambitious AI assistant Copilot is struggling to meet expectations more than a year after its September 2023 launch, according to a comprehensive Business Insider investigation. CEO Satya Nadella had promised the tool would “fundamentally transform our relationship with technology,” but customers, competitors, and even Microsoft’s own employees are expressing serious doubts about its effectiveness.
Customer satisfaction remains alarmingly low. A Gartner survey of 123 IT leaders found that only four reported Copilot provided significant value to their companies. Nearly 75% said employees struggled to integrate the tool into daily routines, 57% reported users felt it didn’t deliver expected value, and 53% cited too many inaccurate results. The AI assistant, priced at $30 per month per user, effectively doubles Microsoft 365 licensing fees, leading some customers to cancel subscriptions after trial periods.
Security concerns have emerged as a critical issue. Copilot’s ability to browse and index all company information has exposed permission vulnerabilities at many organizations. The tool can inadvertently grant employees access to sensitive documents, executive emails, and HR data that were technically accessible but practically hidden before. In the Gartner survey, 40% of IT managers delayed implementation for at least three months due to “oversharing and security concerns.”
Microsoft’s AI spending has reached unprecedented levels. The company’s capital expenditures hit a record $20 billion in its most recent quarter, with AI-related expenses now exceeding the company’s entire payroll of 228,000 employees for the first time in Microsoft’s history. Goldman Sachs estimates tech companies will invest over $1 trillion in AI development over the next few years, raising questions about return on investment.
Competitors are capitalizing on Copilot’s struggles. Salesforce CEO Marc Benioff has aggressively criticized the product, calling it “Clippy 2.0” and launching a competing product called Agentforce. “Microsoft has really disappointed so many of our customers,” Benioff told BI. “They have not delivered any competitive capability.”
Internal doubts are growing within Microsoft. Current and former employees interviewed by Business Insider expressed concerns about premature product releases and unrealistic expectations. “I really feel like I’m living in a group delusion here at Microsoft,” one longtime employee said, adding that “the support isn’t there for AI to do 75% of what Microsoft claims it’ll do.” Another executive offered a blunt assessment: “About one out of 10 times is magic. The rest of the time it’s: Why do we even try?”
Despite the criticism, Microsoft defends its strategy, citing success stories like Lumen Technologies projecting $50 million in annual savings and pointing to adoption by 70% of Fortune 500 companies.
Key Quotes
I really feel like I’m living in a group delusion here at Microsoft. The company touts that ‘AI is going to revolutionize everything,’ but the support isn’t there for AI to do 75% of what Microsoft claims it’ll do.
A longtime Microsoft employee speaking anonymously to Business Insider, revealing internal skepticism about the company’s AI ambitions and the gap between marketing promises and actual capabilities.
About one out of 10 times is magic. The rest of the time it’s: Why do we even try?
A Microsoft executive’s blunt internal assessment of Copilot’s performance, highlighting the inconsistency and reliability issues plaguing the AI assistant despite massive investment.
Microsoft has really disappointed so many of our customers. They have not delivered any competitive capability.
Salesforce CEO Marc Benioff speaking to Business Insider, capitalizing on Copilot’s struggles to promote his company’s competing Agentforce product and position Salesforce as a more reliable AI partner.
There’s a gap between the ambitious vision and what users are actually experiencing. Internally, we’re calling it growing pains. We are building the plane as we fly it.
A Microsoft employee close to Copilot acknowledging the disconnect between the company’s grand promises and the reality of customer experiences, suggesting the product was released prematurely.
Our Take
Microsoft’s Copilot struggles reveal a fundamental tension in the AI industry: the pressure to ship products quickly versus the need for mature, reliable technology. The company appears to have prioritized market positioning over product readiness, betting that first-mover advantage would outweigh initial quality issues. This strategy is backfiring as customers discover security vulnerabilities and inconsistent performance.
The security concerns are particularly telling—they expose how AI tools can amplify existing organizational weaknesses in data governance. Companies that haven’t properly configured permissions are suddenly vulnerable in ways they never were before. This suggests the AI revolution may require a parallel revolution in enterprise data management.
Most significantly, the internal dissent at Microsoft signals that even true believers are questioning the AI hype. When employees at the company leading the generative AI charge express doubts about delivering on promises, it suggests the entire industry may need to recalibrate expectations and timelines for AI transformation.
Why This Matters
This story represents a critical inflection point for the generative AI industry. Microsoft’s struggles with Copilot raise fundamental questions about whether the technology is mature enough to justify the trillion-dollar investment wave sweeping through tech. As one of the most well-resourced AI deployments in enterprise software, Copilot’s difficulties signal potential challenges for the entire sector.
The security vulnerabilities exposed by Copilot highlight a broader issue with AI tools that require deep access to organizational data. Companies rushing to deploy AI may face similar permission and data governance challenges, potentially slowing enterprise adoption across the industry.
Wall Street’s growing skepticism matters significantly. Goldman Sachs’ warning about “too much spend, too little benefit” and Marc Andreessen’s comments about AI hitting a “ceiling on capabilities” suggest the AI hype cycle may be entering a more critical phase. If Microsoft—with its massive resources and OpenAI partnership—cannot demonstrate clear ROI, investor enthusiasm for AI investments could cool rapidly.
The competitive dynamics are also shifting. Salesforce’s aggressive positioning against Copilot shows how established enterprise software companies are using Microsoft’s stumbles to promote their own AI strategies, potentially fragmenting the market and creating uncertainty for customers trying to choose AI platforms.
Recommended Reading
For those interested in learning more about artificial intelligence, machine learning, and effective AI communication, here are some excellent resources: